Docket No:  UM 1002 Docket Name:  WAH CHANG VS PACIFIC POWER & LIGHT Submit Public Comment Subject Company:  PACIFIC POWER     WAH CHANG, Petitioner, vs. PACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER, Respondent. In The Matter of the Petition to Protect WAH CHANG from paying unjust and unreasonable costs for power thru PACIFICORP, filed pursuant to OAR 860-013-0020 and ORS 756.040(1).... Filing Date:  12/1/2000       Order:  09-343 Order Signed:  9/2/2009   Email Service List (semi-colon delimited)      Email Service List (comma delimited)   If you experience problems with the above 'Email Service List' links, please try one of these: Service List Popup (semi-colon delimited)     Service List Popup (comma delimited)

ACTIONS SERVICE LIST SCHEDULE Public Comments Sort By Date        Sort By Type Date: 6/28/2010 Action:  APPEAL      Description Corrected pages of Transcript of Hearing on 8/7/07 & 8/8/07, as follows: Pages 38, 84, 107, 109, 115, 119, 147, and 200 (Page 38 is CONFIDENTIAL and is located in envelope marked Item 219- Corrected) for Court of Appeals, Appellate Court No. CA A143692, to Gwen Keil, Department of Justice, Appellate Division, via shuttle mail. PUC appeal #10-01.  Date: 6/16/2010 Action:  TRANSCRIPT      Description CORRECTIONS-Per ALJ's 3/15/10 Ruling, corrected pages of Transcript of Hearing on 8/7/07 & 8/8/07, Pages 38, 84,107, 109, 115, 119, 147, and 200. Page 38 is CONFIDENTIAL and located in locked cabinet in Env. No. 181(26). Filed by Susan Leedham, Leedham Court Reporting, Inc.  Date: 3/25/2010 Action:  APPEAL      Description Amended Transmittal of Entire Record (shortened) and Certificate for Court of Appeals, Appellate Court No. CA A143692, to Gwen Keil, Department of Justice, Appellate Division, via shuttle mail. PUC appeal #10-01.  Date: 3/15/2010 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Powers' Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION GRANTED. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail on 3/15/10.  Date: 3/10/2010 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Unopposed Motion to Correct the Record; Confidential Five -page Griffith Declaration to PacifiCorp's Post-Hearing Brief previously filed on 10/15/07 in Envelope #181(32) in locked cabinet; electronically filed by Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd. 3/11/10.  Date: 2/23/2010 Action:  APPEAL      Description Transmittal of Entire Record (shortened) and Certificate for Court of Appeals, Appellate Court No. CA A143692, to Gwen Keil, Department of Justice, Appellate Division, via shuttle mail. PUC appeal #10-01.  Date: 12/7/2009 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description WAH CHANG's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 01-149; Electronically filed. Qualified person thereunder: James H. Denham. Hard copy rec'd 12/8/09.  Date: 12/2/2009 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description PACIFIC POWER's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 01-149; Electronically filed; Hard copies rec'd 12/3/09. Qualified persons thereunder: Lawrence Reichman, Robert Aldisert, Kathleen Dent, and Natalie Hocken.   Date: 12/1/2009 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description WAH CHANG's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 01-149; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams. Qualified person thereunder: Thomas W. Sondag; Hard copy rec'd 12/2/09.  Date: 10/29/2009 Action:  APPEAL      Description Petition for Review Judicial Review in the Oregon Court of Appeals; challenging Order No. 09-343; copy filed via certified mail by Thomas W. Sondag.  Date: 9/2/2009 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description The Commission takes official notice of Staff's 6/12/03 Report: Trading Activities by Portland General Electric, PacifiCorp, and Idaho Power Company during the Western Energy Crisis of 2000-2001; Did They Violate Any Oregon Statutes, Rules, or Orders?; pursuant to Order No. 09-343.  Date: 9/2/2009 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description The Commission takes official notice of Staff Report for September 21, 2004, Public Meeting (Item No. 5), pursuant to Order No. 09-343. Electronic versiaon available at: http://www.puc.state.or.us/PUC/meetings/pmemos/2004/092104/reg5.pdf  Date: 9/2/2009 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   09-343    Description Order No. 09-343 signed by Commissioners Lee Beyer, John Savage, and Ray Baum; DISPOSITION: RELIEF DENIED; COMPLAINT DISMISSED. Copies served electronically on 9-2-09 and mailed via U.S. Mail on 9-3-09.  Date: 12/17/2008 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER's Response to Wah Chang's Request for Official Notice; Filed electronically by Robert L. Aldisert; Hard copy rec'd 12/19/08.   Date: 12/8/2008 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description PACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER's letter stating opposition to Wah Chang's Request for Official Notice and intent to file a Response; Filed electronically by Lawrence Reichman; Hard copy rec'd 12/9/08.  Date: 12/3/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's Request for Official Notice, together with Exhibits A-C; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams; Hard copy rec'd 12/4/08.  Date: 10/20/2008 Action:  ORAL ARGUMENTS      Description NOTICE OF HEARING (Oral Arguments); Copies served electronically 10/20/08 and via U.S. Mail 10/21/08. ORAL ARGUMENTS scheduled 11/12/2008 1:30 PM City: SALEM Room: MAIN HEARING ROOM Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Reporter: NONE Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK   Date: 10/20/2008 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: ORAL ARGUMENT PROCEDURE ADOPTED; MOTION GRANTED; Copies served electronically 10/20/08 and via U.S. Mail 10/21/08.  Date: 10/14/2008 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Exhibits WC/1301-WC/1307, filed together with Unopposed Motion to Admit into Evidence Responses to Information Requests by Administrative Law Judge. Filed electronically 10/14/08 and hard copies rec'd 10/15/08. (See 10/14/08 Motion entry for electronic version.)   Date: 10/14/2008 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Unopposed Motion to Admit into Evidence Responses to Information Requests by Administrative Law Judge; together with exhibits WC/1301-WC/1307. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 10/15/08.  Date: 9/3/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFIC POWER's Notice of Change of Service List; replacing counsel James Van Nostrand with Robert L. Aldisert. Electronically filed by Natalie L. Hocken; Hard conformed copy rec'd 9/5/08. Hard copy signed original rec'd 9/8/08.  Date: 8/8/2008 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Wah Chang's Response to Pacific Power's letter dated July 29, 2008 re: Snohomish; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams; Hard copy rec'd 8/11/08.  Date: 7/31/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's Response to ALJ Ruling Dated June 26, 2008; together with Attachments 1-3; Filed electronically by Richard Williams; Hard copy rec'd 8/1/08.  Date: 7/30/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER's letter with copy of Supreme Court Decision to provide further support of the Company's position; Filed in hard copy by Christopher L. Garrett.; Electronic version and Certificate of Service rec'd 8/1/08.   Date: 7/30/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp, dba PACIFIC POWER's Response to 6-26-08 ALJ Ruling (labeled ALJ DRs 2-4); Filed electronically by Ariel Son for Natalie Hocken; Hard copy rec'd 7/31/08.  Date: 6/26/2008 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: FURTHER INFORMATION REQUESTED; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 6/26/08.  Date: 3/31/2008 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response and Attachments to ALJ Power's 2/7/08 Ruling; Filed electronically by Natalie L. Hocken, together with cd; Hard copy rec'd 4/1/08.  Date: 2/7/2008 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Ruling; DISPOSITION: Proceedings Reopened; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 2/7/08.  Date: 1/29/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's letter to ALJ Power in response to Wah Chang's letter of 1/25/08 requesting status of scheduling of oral argument. Filed electronically by Christopher Garrett; Hard copy rec'd 1/30/08.  Date: 1/25/2008 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's letter requesting status of scheduling of oral argument, with attachment of pp. 212-213 of hearing transcript; Filed in hard copy by Richard H. Williams; Electronic version with Certificate of Service rec'd 1/25/08; Hard copy of COS rec'd 1/29/08. (transcript pages are not posted electronically due to court reporter agreement).  Date: 12/7/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Ruling; DISPOSITION: Motions to Compel Denied; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 12/7/07.  Date: 11/21/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Declaration of Charles J. Cicchetti and Jeffrey A. Dubin in Response to Wah Chang's Renewed, Supplemental and Alternative Motions to Compel Compliance with DR 203; electronically filed by Christopher L. Garrett. Hard copy rec'd 11/23/07.  Date: 11/21/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response to Wah Chang's Renewed, Supplemental and Alternative Motions to Compel Compliance with DR 203; electronically filed by Christopher L. Garrett. Hard copy rec'd 11/23/07.  Date: 11/13/2007 Action:  BRIEF      Description WAH CHANG's Post-Hearing Reply Brief and Affidavit of Robert McCullough in Support of Reply Brief. (Documents are confidential. They are located in locked cabinet, envelopes #181(30) & (31)). Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 11/13/07  Date: 11/12/2007 Action:  BRIEF      Description PACIFICORP's Reply Brief. Electronically filed by Christopher L. Garrett. Hard copy rec'd 11/14/07.  Date: 11/6/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description Wah Chang's Renewed, Supplemental and Alternative Motions to Compel Compliance with DR 203 including Affidavit of Richard H. Williams with Exhibits A thru F and Affidavit of Robert McCullough with Exhibits A thru F. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd. 11/7/07.  Date: 10/15/2007 Action:  BRIEF      Description WAH CHANG's Post-Hearing brief (Entire brief is Confidential and located in Envelope #181(29) in locked cabinet); filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/15/2007 Action:  BRIEF      Description PACIFIC POWER's Post-Hearing Opening Brief (redacted version) (Confidential version is located in Envelope #181(28); electronically filed by Christopher L. Garrett. Hard copy rec'd 10/16/07.  Date: 9/10/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE REPLY DENIED. Copies served electronically 9/10/07 and via U.S. Mail 9/11/07.  Date: 9/7/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's letter with hard copy of Motion to Strike, originally filed electronically on 8/1/07 to supplement official file with hard copy. (See 8/1/07 action entry for electronic version of motion.)  Date: 8/31/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to File Reply in Support of Motion for Finding Regarding PacifiCorp's Participiation in Electricity Market Manipulation. Electronically filed by James Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd. 9/4/07.  Date: 8/29/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Affidavit of Christopher L. Garrett in Support of PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Motion to Compel Full Response to Data Request No. 203; electronically filed by James M. Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd 8/30/07.  Date: 8/29/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response to Wah Chang's Motion to Compel Full Response to Data Request No. 203; electronically filed by James M. Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd 8/30/07.   Date: 8/28/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion for Leave to File Reply in Support of Motion for Findng Regarding PacifiCorp's Participation in Electricity Market Manipulation, with copy of reply in support of motion. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd. 8/29/07.  Date: 8/22/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response to Wah Chang's Motion for Finding Regarding PacifiCorp's Participation in Electricity Market Manipulation with Attachments 1 - 3 (Confidential Attachment 3 is located in locked cabinet, envelope #181(27). Electronically filed by by Christopher L. Garrett on behalf of James M. Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd 8/23/07.  Date: 8/22/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Power's Ruling shortening time for PacifiCorp to reply to Wah Chang's motion not later than August 29, 2007. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail on 8/22/07.  Date: 8/21/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG'S Motion to Compel Full Response to Data Request No. 203 and Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in Support of Motion to Compel Full Response to Data Request No. 203. Expedited consideration requested. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 8/23/07.  Date: 8/21/2007 Action:  TRANSCRIPT      Description Transcript* of Hearing on 8/7/07 & 8/8/07, Vol. I, pgs 1-25, 54, & 80-166, and Vol. II, pgs. 167-215; together with invoice. (Pages 26-53 & 55-79 are CONFIDENTIAL and located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181(26), & disk.) Filed by Susan Leedham, Leedham Court Reporting, Inc. (*Also see 6/16/10 entry for CORRECTIONS-Per ALJ's 3/15/10 Ruling, corrected pages of Transcript of Hearing on 8/7/07 & 8/8/07, Pages 38, 84,107, 109, 115, 119, 147, and 200. Page 38 is CONFIDENTIAL and located in locked cabinet in Env. No. 181(26).)  Date: 8/13/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Exhibit 73, (supplemental) to "replace" WC/1136 filed at 8/7/07 hearing; Filed in hard copy by Christopher L. Garrett on behalf of James M. Van Nostrand. Replacement filing made electronically 8/15/07, and in hard copy 8/16/07 to correct exhibit numbering (PacifiCorp/73/Nostrand).   Date: 8/8/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Exhibit List from 8/7/07-8/8/07 Hearing. (Exhibit WC/1140 rec'd at hearing is CONFIDENTIAL and located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181(25).  Date: 8/8/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Sur-Surrebuttal Testimony of Berne Martin Howard and Robert McCullough (WC/1204/Howard and McCullough); Filed by Richard H. Williams at hearing 8/8/07; together with electronic version on CD.  Date: 8/7/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Revised Supplemental Reply Testimony of Charles J. Cicchetti, Ph.D., and Jeffrey A. Dubin, Ph.D. previously filed on 7/30/07 (PacifiCorp/33/Cicchetti-Dubin) Confidential and Redacted Versions; Filed by James M. Van Nostrand at 8/7/07 hearing. Electronic version and certificate of service rec'd 8/15/07; Hard copy certificate of service rec'd 8/16/07. (CONFIDENTIAL pages 2 through 5, 10, 11, & 14 of PacifiCorp/33/ Cicchetti-Dubin are located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181(22) (A).)  Date: 8/7/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Revised and Redlined version of Exhibit 32 Accompanying Reply Testimony of Charles Cicchetti (PacifiCorp/32); Filed by James M. Van Nostrand at 8/7/07 hearing; Electronic version and certificate of service rec'd 8/15/07; Hard copy certificate of service rec'd 8/16/07.  Date: 8/7/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Affidavit of Deborah J. Stare Verifying the Prepared Direct Testimony of Deborah J. State prefiled (WC/900); Filed by Richard Williams.  Date: 8/7/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion for Finding Regarding PacifiCorp's Participation in Electricity Market Manipulation; together with Affidavit of Robert McCullough In Support; Supplemental Affidavit of Robert McCullough; and Affidavit of Deborah J. Stare in Support of Wah Chang's Motion. (All documents are CONFIDENTIAL and located in locked cabinet, Env. nos 181 (23) (A-D). Filed in hard copy by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 8/6/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP'S Revised Exhibit 31 (and marked version) to previously filed testimony of Charles Cicchetti (PacifiCorp/31/Cicchetti); Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 8/7/07.  Date: 8/6/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's letter to ALJ Power advising it will play video of Stan Watters and audio of trader conversations during 8/7/07 hearing, and will offer the recordings as exhibits; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams; Hard copy rec'd 8/7/07 at hearing (information is CONFIDENTIAL and not available electronically.)  Date: 8/3/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Reply to Wah Chang's Motion to Strike; Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 8/6/07.  Date: 8/1/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Order Shortening Time Ruling; DISPOSITION: Time Shortened for Reply; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 8/1/07.  Date: 8/1/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Strike Supplemental Reply Testimony and Request for Expedited Consideration; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd. 9/7/07.  Date: 7/30/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Supplemental Reply Testimony of Charles J. Cicchetti, Ph.D., and Jeffrey A. Dubin, Ph.D. (PacifiCorp/33/Cicchetti-Dubin); and (PacifiCorp/34/Dubin); Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 7/31/07. (See also 8/7/07 revised filing action entry.) (CONFIDENTIAL pages 2, 3, 4, 5, 10, 11 & 14 of PacifiCorp/33/Cicchetti-Dubin are located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181(22).)  Date: 7/30/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Ruling; DISPOSITION: Parties Directed to Identify Confidential Documents; Copies served electronically 7/30/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/31/07.   Date: 7/30/2007 Action:  CANCELLATION/CHANGE      Description AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING scheduled 8/7/2007 9:30 AM City: SALEM Room: SMALL HEARING RM, 2ND FL Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Reporter: S. LEEDHAM (Tape 1 of 2; 8/7/07 Hearing contains confidential material and is located in locked cabinet, Env. 181(24).) Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK Amended Notice of Hearing (previously issued 7/18/07); Copies served electronically 7/30/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/31/07.   Date: 7/27/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE CONFERENCE REPORT      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Ruling and Conference Report; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO STRIKE DENIED; LEAVE TO FILE SUR-REBUTTAL GRANTED; CROSS-EXAMINATION SCHEDULE ADOPTED. Copies served electronically 7/27/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/30/07.  Date: 7/27/2007 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF TELEPHONE CONFERENCE scheduled 7/27/2007, 2:00 PM Room: VIA TELEPHONE Reporter: NONE Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 7/27/07.   Date: 7/26/2007 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description WAH CHANG's objection to proposed schedule; electronically filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 7/26/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE CORRESPONDENCE      Description ALJ Power's e-mail correspondence re: proposed schedule. Electronically served 7/26/07.  Date: 7/26/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's comments re: proposed schedule; Electronically filed by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 7/30/07.  Date: 7/25/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's Reply to PacifiCorp's Motion to Strike Portions of Wah Chang's Rebuttal Testimony or, in the Alternative, for Leave to Submit Limited Sur-Rebuttal Testimony; together with supporting Affidavit of Richard H. Williams, and Exhibits A-E. Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams (CD included.); Hard copy rec'd 7/25/07. (Reply is CONFIDENTIAL and located in Envelope # 181(21)).  Date: 7/25/2007 Action:  CROSS EXAM STATEMENT      Description Wah Chang's Cross-Examination Statement. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams, cd included. Hard copy rec'd 7/25/07.  Date: 7/25/2007 Action:  CROSS EXAM STATEMENT      Description PACIFICORP's Cross-Examination Statement. Electronically filed by James M. Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd. 7/26/07.  Date: 7/19/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Ruling; DISPOSITION: Time Shortened for Reply; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 7/19/07.  Date: 7/18/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues (Notice of Hearing) and Ruling (regarding cross-examination statements); Copies served electronically 7/18/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/19/07. (Amended Notice of Hearing issued 7/30/07)  Date: 7/18/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion to Strike Portions of WAH CHANG's Rebuttal Testimony or, in the alternative, for leave to submit limited sur-rebuttal Testimony; Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 7/19/07.  Date: 7/18/2007 Action:  HEARING      Description NOTICE OF HEARING (and Ruling) scheduled 8/1/2007 9:30 AM begin, 8/8/2007 5:00 PM end. City: SALEM Room: SMALL HEARING RM, 2ND FL Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Reporter: S. LEEDHAM Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK Notice of Hearing and Ruling; Copies served electronically 7/18/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/19/07. (See 7/18/07 Ruling entry for electronic version) Amended Notice served electronically 7/30/07 and via U.S. Mail 7/31/07.  Date: 7/6/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Rebuttal Testimony and Exhibits to include: (1) Rebuttal Testimony and Exhibits of Robert McCullough WC/869 - 871) (WC/869 is confidential and located in locked cabinet, env. #181(17); (2) Rebuttal Testimony and Exhibits of Berne Martin (WC/1200 - 1203) (pages 13-16 of WC/1200 and WC/1203 are confidential and located in locked cabinet, envelops #181(19) and 181(20), respectively); (3) Deposition Testimony of Charles Cicchetti (WC/1011) (WC/1011 is confidential and located in locked cabinet, env. # 181(18); and (4) Exhibits WC/1130 - 1135. Electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 7/6/07. (CD included)  Date: 6/7/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION (re: assumption of risk) DENIED. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail on 6/7/07.  Date: 6/4/2007 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response to WAH CHANG's Motion to Exclude "Assumption of Risk" as an Issue; Filed electronically by Christopher L. Garrett for James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 6/5/07.  Date: 5/24/2007 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Reply Testimony of Charles Cicchetti and Exhibits (PacifiCorp/23-32); Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 5/25/07. Pages 81 & 85 of Exhibit 23 are confidential and located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181 (16). (Redacted pages for hard copy rec'd 5/29/07.) (See also 8/7/07 action entry for revised filing.)  Date: 5/21/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Letter from James M. Van Nostrand regarding hearing dates in follow up to his letter of 5/17/07 re: procedural schedule; Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 5/22/07.  Date: 5/21/2007 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Patrick Power's Memorandum; DISPOSITION: Schedule Amended; Copies served electronically 5/21/07 and via U.S. Mail 5/22/07.  Date: 5/18/2007 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Exclude "Assumption of Risk" as an Issue, together with Attachments A & B; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams; Hard copy rec'd 5/21/07.  Date: 5/17/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Letter from James M. Van Nostrand regarding change in procedural schedule; Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 5/18/07.  Date: 3/8/2007 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's update re: contact information for Natalie Hocken; Filed electronically by James M. Van Nostrand; Hard copy rec'd 3/9/07.   Date: 12/13/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE CONFERENCE REPORT      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Status Conference Memorandum setting the new schedule in the docket. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 12/13/06.  Date: 11/28/2006 Action:  NOTICE      Description PACIFICORP's Notice of Substitution of Counsel; electronically filed by Diane M. Philips on behalf of James M. Van Nostrand. Hard copy rec'd 11/29/06.  Date: 11/28/2006 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF TELEPHONE STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled 12/11/2006, at 1:30 PM Room: VIA TELEPHONE Reporter: NONE Law Judge: KIRKPATRICK, TRACI Parties to Dial # 503-378-3003 Notice of Telephone Status Conference served electronically on 11/28/06 and via U.S. Mail 11/29/06.   Date: 7/25/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT DENIED; MOTION TO EXCLUDE DENIED; MOTION TO STRIKE DENIED. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 7/25/06.  Date: 6/30/2006 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's Errata to Appendix 2 to its Response to PacifiCorp's Motion to Strike Petitioner's Direct Testimony and Exhibits; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams and Milo Petranovich; Hard copy rec'd 7/3/06.   Date: 6/30/2006 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Correction to Exhibit WC/904; Filed electronically by Richard H. Williams and Milo Petranovich; Hard copy rec'd 7/3/06. (Confidential dvd disk located in locked cabinet, env. no. 181(10 C) (1).   Date: 6/13/2006 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Notice of Substitution of Counsel, replacing Jay A. Zollinger with Robert L. Aldisert on the docket service list; Filed electronically by Robert L. Aldisert; Hard copy rec'd 6/14/06.  Date: 5/9/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE REPLY TESTIMONY GRANTED. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 5/9/06.  Date: 4/25/2006 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description WAH CHANG's Opposition to PacifiCorp's Motion for Extension of Time To File Reply Testimony; electronically filed by Helen Lyman on behalf of Richard H. Williams.  Date: 4/21/2006 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Reply in Support of Its Motion to Strike Petitioner's Direct Testimony and Exhibits; electronically filed by MaryLou Brown on behalf of Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 4/24/06  Date: 4/21/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: WAH CHANG DIRECTED TO FILE EXPEDITED REPLY. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 4/21/06.  Date: 4/19/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply Testimony; electronically filed by Mary Lou Brown on behalf of Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 4/20/06.  Date: 4/13/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: REPLY TO WAH CHANG'S RESPONSE TO PACIFICORP'S MOTION TO STRIKE PETITIONER'S DIRECT TESTIMONY AND EXHIBITS MAY BE FILED ON OR BEFORE APRIL 21, 2006. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 4/13/06.  Date: 4/12/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time; electronically filed by E. Carrol Proctor on behalf of Jay Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 4/13/06.  Date: 4/7/2006 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's Response to Pacificorp's Motion to Strike Petitioner's Direct Testimony and Exhibits--redacted version (Confidential version is located in Envelope # 181(14) in locked cabinet) with Affidavits of Robert McCullough and Berne Martin Howard; electronically filed by D. J. Stare on behalf of Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 4/10/06. (See also 6-30-06 Errata to Appendix 2 filing)   Date: 4/7/2006 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's Reply in Support of Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order--redacted version (Confidential version is located in Envelope # 181(15) in locked cabinet) with accompanying Affidavits of Robert McCullough and Berne Martin Howard; electronically filed by D.J. Stare on behalf of Richard H. Williams.  Date: 3/27/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: REPLY TIME TO PACIFICORP'S RESPONSE TO MOTION TO EXCLUDE AND PACIFICORP'S MOTION TO STRIKE GRANTED. Copies served electronically 3/27/06 and via U.S. Mail 3/28/06.  Date: 3/24/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time; electronically filed by Helen Lyman for Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/27/06.  Date: 3/16/2006 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Declaration of Susan K. Roberts in Support of PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order; electronically filed by Tammy Goichenberg for Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 3/20/06.  Date: 3/16/2006 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Response to Wah Chang's Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order electronically filed by Tammy Goichenberg for Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 3/20/06.  Date: 3/16/2006 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Declaration of Susan K. Roberts in Support of PacifiCorp's Motion to Strike Petitioner's Direct Testimony and Exhibits; electronically filed by Tammy Goichenberg for Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 3/20/06.   Date: 3/16/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion to Strike Petitioner's Direct Testimony and Exhibits and Memorandum in Support; electronically filed by Tammy Goichenberg for Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 3/20/06.  Date: 3/13/2006 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: RESPONSE TIME TO WAH CHANG'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE INFORMATION FROM PROTECTIVE ORDER GRANTED. Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 3/13/06.  Date: 3/9/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (Expedited Consideration Requested); Filed by Lawrence H. Reichman. (Electronic version was filed 3/2/06, but hard copy was not received; and company refiled it on until 3/8/06; rec'd 3/9/06.)  Date: 2/23/2006 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG'S Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order; Memorandum in Support of Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order (redacted and confidential versions); Affidavit of Robert McCullough in Support of Motion to Exclude Information from Protective Order; and Stipulation Regarding Certain Wah Chang Exhibits (Confidential Memorandum is located in Envelope #181(13) in locked cabinet.) Filed by Richard H. Williams. (CD included.)  Date: 1/4/2006 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG'S Errata to Direct Testimony of Robert McCullough (WC/800/McCullough) (Entire Testimony is Confidential and located in Envelope #181(12) in locked cabinet); hard copy filed by Richard H. Williams. (No electronic version available.)  Date: 12/30/2005 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Direct Testimony of Robert McCullough (WC/806, 807, 809, 815, 823, 825, 827, 834, 836, 840 and 857/McCullough) w/Corrected Exhibit List, CD of all non-Confidential documents, and Exhibit 817 (which is Confidential and located in Envelope #181(11)) hard copy filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 12/15/2005 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's Direct Testimony and Exhibits (with List of Exhibits) of Robert McCullough (WC/800 -868/McCullough) and Deborah J. Stare (WC/900-907); Transcripts of depositions of PacifiCorp personnel (WC/1000-1010); and Other Exhibits (WC/1100-1129). (McCullough Testimony, WC/800, and Exhibits WC/802, 805, 806, 807, 809, 810, 815, 816, 823, 827, 834, 836, 840, 842, 849, 850, 856, 857, 901-907, 1000-1010, 1108, 1118, 1119, 1121-1124, and 1126-1129 are Confidential and located in Envelopes #181(10A-G) in locked cabinet); hard copy filed by Richard H. Williams w/accompanying disk. (Cover letter and list of exhibits may be viewed; testimony is too voluminous to post.) (See also 6-30-06 filing correction to WC/904)  Date: 8/18/2005 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED; SCHEDULE MODIFIED. Copies served electronically 8/18/05 and via mail 8/19/05.  Date: 8/16/2005 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description PACIFICORP's Opposition to Wah Chang's Motion to Extend Current Deadlines; electronically filed by Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 8/17/05.  Date: 8/8/2005 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF PREHEARING CONFERENCE scheduled 8/17/2005 9:30 AM City: SALEM Room: COMMISSION CONF RM--2ND FLR Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Dial In #: 1-877-322-9648; participant code: 551744 Reporter: NONE Law Judge: KIRKPATRICK, TRACI Ruling and Notice of Prehearing Conference served electronically and via mail 8/8/05.   Date: 8/8/2005 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci Kirkpatrick issues Ruling and Notice of Prehearing Conference to address revisions to the docket's schedule. Copies served electronically and via mail 8/8/05.  Date: 8/5/2005 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Extend Time to File Direct Testimony and Request for Scheduling Conference and Expedited Consideration; plus affidavit of Richard H. Williams in support of the motion; electronically filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 8/8/05.  Date: 4/28/2005 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Amended Status Conference Memorandum. Copies served 4/28/05, electronically (and via mail to non-email recipients).  Date: 4/14/2005 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP and WAH CHANG's joint request that the Status Conference Memorandum be amended; electronically filed by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 4/15/05.  Date: 4/13/2005 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Status Conference Memorandum adopting the procedural schedule in the docket. Copies served 4/13/05.  Date: 3/23/2005 Action:  OTHER CORRESPONDENCE (ACKN, SVC, LTR)      Description Notice of Status Conference sent to Joyce Lindner returned by post office with new address. Notice sent to new address 3/24/05.  Date: 3/22/2005 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled 4/12/2005 1:30 PM City: SALEM Room: MAIN HEARING RM--1ST FLR Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Reporter: NONE Law Judge: KIRKPATRICK, TRACI Copies of Notice of Status Conference served 3/22/05.   Date: 3/9/2005 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP'S letter stating PacifiCorp and Wah Chang have reached agreement on several issues; and requesting a scheduling conference within the next 4-6 weeks; faxed by Jay A. Zollinger. Electronically filed and hard copy rec'd 3/10/05.  Date: 2/24/2005 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; Disposition: WAH CHANG'S MOTION TO LIFT STAY GRANTED. Copies served electronically on 2/24/05 and via mail on 2/25/05.  Date: 2/23/2005 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Lift Stay; filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 2/24/05.  Date: 11/16/2004 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci A.G. Kirkpatrick issues Ruling; Disposition: PACIFICORP'S MOTION TO STAY GRANTED; PACIFICORP'S MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED. Copies served electronically and via mail on 11/16/04.  Date: 11/8/2004 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's Memorandum in Opposition to PacifiCorp's Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Petitioner's Third Motion to Compel; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 11/4/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Petitioner's Third Motion to Compel; filed by Lawrence H. Reichman.  Date: 11/2/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Compel Compliance with Data Request (No. 72); filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/22/2004 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description WAH CHANG's Memorandum in Opposition to PacifiCorp's Motion for Extension of Time; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/22/2004 Action:  PROTEST/EXCEPTION/OBJECTION      Description WAH CHANG's Memorandum in Opposition to PacifiCorp's Motion to Stay, with Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in support of motion; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/21/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Petitioner's Motions to Compel; filed by Jay A. Zollinger.  Date: 10/7/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Compel Compliance with Data Requests. Filed by Richard H. Williams. (Filing is conditional, upon refiling of confidential documents.) (Confidential material refiled properly on 10/12. They are locked in cabinet, envelope #181(9).)  Date: 10/7/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Motion to Stay. Filed by Lawrence H. Reichman.  Date: 10/6/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion to Compel Compliance with Deposition Notice, with Exhibits A (Notice of Deposition of PacifiCorp) and B (PacifiCorp's Objections to Petitioner's Notice of Deposition). Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 7/26/2004 Action:  LAW JUDGE CONFERENCE REPORT      Description ALJ Traci A. G. Kirkpatrick issues Prehearing Conference Memorandum in this docket. Copies served electronically on 7/26/04 and via mail on 7/27/04.  Date: 6/30/2004 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description PREHEARING CONFERENCE scheduled 7/23/2004 9:30 AM City: SALEM Room: SMALL HEARING RM--2ND FLR Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST Reporter: NONE Law Judge: KIRKPATRICK, TRACI Notice of Prehearing Conference served electronically on 6/30/04 and via mail on 7/1/04.   Date: 6/28/2004 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Kirkpatrick's Ruling; Disposition: RESPONSE TIME TO WAH CHANG’S SEVENTH DATA REQUEST EXTENDED. Copies served electronically and via mail on 6/28/04.  Date: 6/25/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time to Respond to Petitioner's Seventh Data Request; faxed by Jay Zollinger and Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd. 6/28/04.  Date: 5/27/2004 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   04-305    Description Order No. 04-305 signed by Commissioners Lee Beyer, John Savage and Ray Baum; Disposition: Motion to Reopen Docket and Permit Discovery Approved. Copies served 5/28/04.  Date: 3/10/2004 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's letter stating "why the Commission would err by failing to reopen this docket." FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/11/04.  Date: 3/9/2004 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's letter stating that FERC formally approved PacifiCorp's settlement agreement; FAXED by Mary Lou Brown on behalf of Jay Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 3/10/04.  Date: 3/1/2004 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's Supplemental Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in Support of Wah Chang's Motion for Order Reopening Docket and Permitting Discovery; FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/3/04.  Date: 3/1/2004 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description WAH CHANG's Reply to Opposition to Motion for Order Reopening Docket and Permitting Discovery; FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/3/04.  Date: 2/13/2004 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PACIFICORP's Affidavit of Jay A. Zollinger in Support of PacifiCorp's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Reopen Docket and Permit Discovery (w/exhibits A-F inclusive); filed by Lawrence Reichman.  Date: 2/13/2004 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PACIFICORP's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Reopen Docket and Permit Discovery; filed by Lawrence Reichman.  Date: 1/28/2004 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Traci Kirkpatrick issues ruling granting PacifiCorp's request for an extension of time to respond to petitioner's Motion for Order Reopening Docket and Permitting Discovery no later than Friday, January 13, 2004. Copies served electronically on 1/28/04 and via mail on 1/29/04.  Date: 1/26/2004 Action:  MOTION      Description PACIFICORP's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Petitioner's Motion to Reopen Docket and Permit Discovery; FAXED by Jay A. Zollinger on behalf of Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 1/27/04.  Date: 1/15/2004 Action:  SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION      Description In the Matter of WAH CHANG Motion for Order Reopening Docket and Permitting Discovery, and Affidavit of Richard H. Williams (w/Exhibits A-G). Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 3/13/2003 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   03-153    Description Order No. 03-153 signed by Commissioners Roy Hemmingway, Lee Beyer and Joan H. Smith; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR SUMMARY AFFIRMANCE DENIED; CASE HELD IN ABEYANCE. Copies served 3/17/03.  Date: 12/30/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's letter requesting oral argument on PacifiCorp's Motion for Summary Affirmance of Order No. 01-873; FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 12/31/02.  Date: 12/18/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Reply Regarding Scope of Commission Proceedings; FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 12/19/02.  Date: 12/6/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Memorandum in Opposition to PacifiCorp's Motion for Summary Affirmance of Order No. 01-873; FAXED by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 12/9/02.  Date: 12/6/2002 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Brief Regarding Scope of Commission Proceedings; FAXED by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 12/9/02.  Date: 11/22/2002 Action:  BRIEF      Description Wah Chang's Brief Regarding Hearing Scope, Schedule and Discovery, with Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in Support of Wah Chang's Brief Regarding Hearing Scope, Schedule and Discovery together with Exhibits A through M; Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 11/15/2002 Action:  MOTION      Description PacifiCorp's Motion For Summary Affirmance of Order No. 01-873; FAXED by Jay Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 11/18/02.  Date: 10/31/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's letter responding to ALJ Bergen's Memorandum dated 10/18/02 re: schedule. Filed by Richard H. Williams  Date: 10/18/2002 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Lowell Bergen's Memorandum requesting Wah Chang and PacifiCorp reach an agreement on briefing schedule by end of October 2002. Copies served via fax and mail 10/21/02.  Date: 10/2/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence; Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/2/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Second Supplemental Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in Support of Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence, with attached Exhibits 1-3; Filed by Richard Williams.  Date: 10/2/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Supplemental Affidavit of Richard H. Williams in Support of Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence, with enclosed Exhibit 1; Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 10/2/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence; Filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 9/30/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Affidavit of Richard H. Williams (dated 5/23/02) in Support of Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence, including Exhibits 1-12; Filed by Mary Lou Brown.  Date: 9/30/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's letter disagreeing with PacifiCorp's position; faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 10/02/02.  Date: 9/30/2002 Action:  MOTION      Description Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to Present Additional Evidence (Marion County Circuit Court); filed by MaryLou Brown on behalf of Richard H. Williams.  Date: 9/20/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's letter regarding scheduling deadlines by PacifiCorp and reply by Wah Chang; faxed by Jay Zollinger for Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 9/23/02.  Date: 9/13/2002 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's letter dated 9/11/02 (forwarded by Staff) requesting a status conference to discuss a schedule for the case pursuant to Marion County Circuit Court Judge Dickey's Order entered on July 23, 2002, together with a copy of the order in Marion County Circuit Court Case No. 01C20598; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 7/1/2002 Action:  INITIAL (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description (1) Circuit Court Judge Don A. Dickey's letter dated June 18, 2002, to parties telling them what his decision is in Marion County Circuit Court, Case No. 01C20598; Filed by the Department of Justice 7/1/02.  Date: 2/14/2002 Action:  APPEAL      Description Transmittal of Record and Certificate Mailed To Marion County Circuit Court And Attorneys, Case No. 01C20598. Our Case Number is 02-2.   Date: 12/14/2001 Action:  APPEAL      Description Summons Received, Marion County Circuit Court, No. 01C20598, Attorney For WAH CHANG, a division of TDY INDUSTRIES, INC., Richard H. Williams: Appeal of Order No. 01-873. Judge Don Dickey. (dated 12/14/01).  Date: 10/15/2001 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   01-873    Description Order No. 01-873 signed by Commissioners Roy Hemmingway, Lee Beyer, and Joan H. Smith; DISPOSITION: Contract Terms Affirmed. Copies served 10/16/01.  Date: 9/5/2001 Action:  ORAL ARGUMENTS      Description Notice to parties of 9/24/01 Special Public Meeting at 1:30 p.m. (Oral Argument.) (See separate action entry for ALJ Bergen's Ruling 9/5/01.)  Date: 9/5/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Ruling notifying parties of 9/24/01 Special Public Meeting at 1:30 p.m. (Oral Argument) Copies served on 9/5/01.  Date: 8/29/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's letter objecting to Wah Chang's request for oral argument, FAXED by Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 8/30/01.  Date: 8/22/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's request for opportunity to present oral argument to the Commission before it makes its decision; faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 8/24/01.  Date: 8/17/2001 Action:  BRIEF      Description WAH CHANG's Post-Hearing Closing Brief together with confidential Appendix A (in envelope # 181(7) in locked cabinet); filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 8/3/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Post-Hearing Brief with Appendices A [confidential located in locked cabinet envelope #181(6)], B, C, and D; filed by Jay A. Zollinger.  Date: 7/11/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PACIFICORP's Updated Index of Respondent's Exhibits. Exhibits that were introduced at the 6/22/01 hearing: 15/1-10, *16/1-11, *17/1-2, 18/1-2, 19/1-2, 20/1-2, *21/Griffith/1-3 [*confidential exhibits -- see locked cabinet env. #181(5)]. Filed by Jay A. Zollinger dated 7/10/01.  Date: 7/11/2001 Action:  BRIEF      Description Wah Chang's Post Hearing Opening Brief, filed by Milo Petranovich.  Date: 7/2/2001 Action:  TRANSCRIPT      Description Transcript of Hearing on 6/22/01 (157 pgs.), Confidential materials in envelope #181(4) in locked cabinet; together with invoice dtd 6/29/01; filed by Chris Roemmich of Bolam & Assocs.  Date: 6/29/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description WAH CHANG's items to follow-up the PUC hearing held 6/22/01: additional copies of Exhibit 700, 701, 702, petitioner's prefiled exhibit list (revised), and hearing exhibit list (revised to include exhibit 715). Filed by Richard H. Williams (dated 6/28/01).  Date: 6/22/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Wah Chang's Hearing Exhibits with Exhibits 700 - 702 and 704 - 714 admitted at hearing; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 6/15/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PacifiCorp's Index of Exhibits; faxed by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 6/18/01.  Date: 6/15/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's Confidential Stipulation concerning the facts surrounding recent sales of electricity by Oremet (in locked Cabinet envelope # 181(3); Wah Chang agreed to allow PacifiCorp to file this evidence after the deadline for submitting evidence; filed by Jay A. Zollinger.  Date: 6/15/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Wah Chang's prefiled (4/17/01) exhibit list (WC 100, WC 101, WC 102, WC 103, WC 200, WC 300, WC 301) and prefiled (6/12/01) exhibit list (WC 400, WC 500, WC 600, WC 601, and WC 602) and Master Exhibit List; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 6/12/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Wah Chang's prefiled Rebuttal Testimony (Eric Larson, Berne Martin Howard, and Robert McCullough) and Exhibits (Exhibits 601 and 602, Robert McCullough); filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 6/7/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Rulings on PacifiCorp's Motion to Compel Wah Chang to file adequate responses to several PacifiCorp data requests. Copies served 6/7/01.  Date: 6/5/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's Reply Memorandum in Support of its Motion to Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests; faxed by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 6/6/01.  Date: 6/1/2001 Action:  OTHER CORRESPONDENCE (ACKN, SVC, LTR)      Description PacifiCorp's Correspondence (including courtesy copy of prefiled testimony) regarding unsuccessful attempt to resolve discovery disputes with Wah Chang and stating that PacifiCorp reserves the right to submit additional testimony and evidence concerning any documents and information that Wah Chang is compelled to produce; parties are also drafting stipulation regarding submission of evidence about a recent sale of power by Oremet; Wah Chang has agreed that PacifiCorp can file the stipulation after 6/1 deadline for filing direct testimony;   Date: 6/1/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description PacifiCorp's prefiled testimony of Larry Blaufus (PacifiCorp/1), Bruce Griswold (PacifiCorp/2), William R. Griffith (PacifiCorp/13), and confidential testimony of Mark Tallman (PacifiCorp/3) [located in locked cabinet env. #181(2) and Exhibits (PacifiCorp/4 thru PacifiCorp/12; filed by Jay A. Zollinger.  Date: 6/1/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests (includes Affidavit of James H. Denham) ; faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 6/4/01.   Date: 6/1/2001 Action:  HEARING      Description HEARING scheduled 6/22/2001 9:30 AM begin, 6/29/2001 end. City: SALEM OR Room: SMALL HEARING ROOM Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Reporter: BOLAM Law Judge: BERGEN, LOWELL Notice of Hearing mailed on 6/1/01.   Date: 6/1/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Memorandum asking parties to submit a table of their prefiled exhibits by 6/15/01. Copies served 6/1/01.  Date: 5/25/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Ruling regarding PacifiCorp's Motion To Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests and Wah Chang's letter of resopnse and revising schedule, as follows: Wah Chang must filed a response by 6/1/01. PacifiCorp's Testimony is due 6/1/01. Wah Chang's Rebuttal Testimony, if any, due 6/12/01. Copies served via fax and mail on 5/25/01.  Date: 5/23/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Correspondence to Judge Bergen Responding to PacifiCorp's Motion to Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests; Affidavit of Jay A. Zollinger in Support of PacifiCorp's Motion to Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests with Exhibits A and B; faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd. 5/24/01.  Date: 5/23/2001 Action:  MOTION      Description PacifiCorp's Motion to Compel Adequate Responses to Data Requests (Expedited Consideration Requests); faxed by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd. 5/24/01.  Date: 4/25/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's corrected prefiled testimony of Berne Howard, page 16, WC 200; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 4/17/2001 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Wah Chang's prefiled Direct Testimony and Exhibits: (1) Testimony of Eric Larson, Exhibits 101, 102, and 103 (Confidential portion-102-in locked cabinet envelope #181); (2) Testimony of Berne Martin Howard; and (3) Testimony of Robert McCullough (Confidential portion-pgs. 57 through 63-in locked cabinet envelope #181(1)], Exhibit 301; filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 3/27/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Correspondence regarding a modification of the schedule set out in ALJ's 3/16/01 Ruling (attached); parties agree, upon ALJ's approval, that Wah Chang's evidence will be delayed one day for each day after March 21 (the day PacifiCorp's response was due but not met) that PacifiCorp fails to provide information required by ALJ's 3/16/01 Ruling; faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/28/01.  Date: 3/16/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Ruling with the following schedule: Wah Chang will serve any follow up discovery requests by Mar. 26, 2001 PacifiCorp will respond to those discovery requests by Apr. 2, 2001 Evidence of Wah Chang due Apr. 6, 2001 Petition to Intervene deadline Apr. 12, 2001 Evidence of PacifiCorp due May 4, 2001 Rebuttal evidence due May 18, 2001 Hearing June 6, 2001 Copies served 3/16/01.  Date: 3/6/2001 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description PROCEDURAL CONFERENCE scheduled 3/14/2001 10:00 AM City: SALEM OR Room: SMALL HEARING ROOM Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE - STE 215 Reporter: NONE Law Judge: BERGEN, LOWELL Notice of Procedural Conference mailed on 3/5/01 and faxed on 3/6/01.   Date: 3/5/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Ruling Granting Wah Chang's Motion for Discovery in Part. Copies served 3/5/01.  Date: 2/28/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Correspondence listing dates Wah Chang and PacifiCorp are available for a procedural conference, faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 3/1/01.  Date: 2/21/2001 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   01-185    Description Order No. 01-185, signed by Chairman Ron Eachus and Commissioner Roger Hamilton; Commissioner Smith was Unavailable for Signature; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR INTERIM RELIEF DENIED. Copies served 2/22/01.   Date: 2/21/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Reply in Support of Motion to Compel, faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 2/22/01.  Date: 2/14/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's Response to Wah Chang's Motion to Compel, with Thomas Beck's Affidavit in Support, faxed by Jay Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 2/15/01.  Date: 2/14/2001 Action:  ORAL ARGUMENTS      Description ORAL ARGUMENT scheduled 2/27/2001 10:30 AM City: SALEM, OR Room: MAIN HEARING ROOM Building: PUC BLDG Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Law Judge: LOWELL BERGEN Notice of Oral Argument mailed on 2/14/01.   Date: 2/5/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to Reply and Proposed Reply, faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 2/6/01.  Date: 2/2/2001 Action:  PROTECTIVE ORDER      Order No:   01-149    Description Order No. 01-149 signed by Lowell Bergen, Administrative Law Judge; DISPOSITION: Motion Granted; IT IS ORDERED that the Standard Protective Order, attached as Appendix A, shall govern the disclosure of confidential information in this case.  Date: 2/2/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's letter stating that Wah Chang and PacifiCorp have reached an agreement regarding the submission of additional material beyond that contempated in Mr. Williams' 1/4/01 letter to ALJ; Wah Chang's response to PacifiCorp's Motion for Leave to Respond to Wah Chang's Closing Memorandum due 2/5/01; if motion is granted, PacifiCorp agrees to withdraw its opposition to Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to File the Supplemental Affidavit of Eric Larson, FAXED by Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd. 2/5/01  Date: 2/2/2001 Action:  MOTION      Description PacifiCorp's Motion for Leave to Respond to Wah Chang's Closing Memorandum and Proposed Response and letter to ALJ Bergen, faxed by Jay A. Zollinger for Lawrence H. Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 2/5/01.  Date: 1/31/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Motion to Compel Answers to Petitioner's First Data Requests and for Expedited Hearing on Motion (Oral Argument Requested) with Exhibits A-D, filed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 1/30/2001 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Bergen's Ruling Granting Wah Chang's Motion for Expedited Treatment of its Motion to be allowed to file Supplemental Affidavit of Eric Larsen; PacifiCorp may file a response to the motion by the close of business on 2/2/01, and Wah Chang may file a reply by the close of business on 2/6/01. Copies mailed to service list and faxed to Larry Reichman and Richard Williams on 1/30/01  Date: 1/26/2001 Action:  MOTION      Description Wah Chang's Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Affidavit of Eric Larson and for Expedited Decision on Motion (with Attachment 1 and Exhibit A), faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 1/29/01.  Date: 1/26/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Closing Memorandum in Support of Motion for Interim Relief (with Attachment 1), faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 1/29/01.  Date: 1/26/2001 Action:  MOTION      Description Joint Stipulated Motion for Adoption of a Protective Order signed by Jay A. Zollinger for Lawrence H. Reichman and Richard H. Williams for John Wiley Gould, filed by Jay A. Zollinger for Lawrence Reichman.   Date: 1/23/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's Reply to Wah Chang's Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Its Motion for Interim Relief and Affidavit of Jay A. Zollinger in support of the Reply (Exhibits A and B included), faxed by Jay A. Zollinger. Hard copy rec'd 1/24/01.  Date: 1/10/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's filing to include: 1) Supplemental Memorandum in support of Motion for Interim Relief/pgs 1-15 2) Affidavit of Robert McCullough/pgs 1-5; 3) Affidavit of Berne Martin Howard/pgs 1-4/attached Dow Jones wholesale electricity price indexes; 4) Affidavit of Eric Larson (facsimile copy; original to follow)/pgs 1-3/attached Pacific Power calculation of billing (Exhibit 1) and Pacific Power & Light Company (Exhibit 2); 5) Affidavit of Richard H. Williams/attached Exhibit A pgs 1-77/Exhibit B pgs 1-99; 6) Cetificate of Service. Filed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy of Affidavit of Eric Larson rec'd 2/7/01.   Date: 1/4/2001 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Complainant's letter to Judge Bergen confirming the following schedule agreed upon at the 1/4/01 conference: 1. Tuesday, 1/9/00 (s/b 01) Wah Chang files a memorandum and affidavits in support of the Motion. 2. Tuesday, 1/23/00 (s/b 01) PacifiCorp files an answering memorandum and affidavits. 3. Friday, 1/26/01 (s/b 00) Wah Chang files reply memorandum. If PacifiCorp determines that Wah Chang's 1/9 filing does not require an extensive response, it will endeavor to file its materials earlier than 1/23. If Wah Chang's 1/9 filing differs materially from the filing as described to Mr. Zollinger in a separate telephone call, the schedule will be revisited at his request. Motion will be submitted on the written record without testimony. Judge will advise parties if he wants to hear oral argument. Judge indicated that the Commission procedures for making a decision based on his recommendation will be determined at a later time. Parties agreed to hand deliver a copy of their respective clients' filings to the other on the due date. Faxed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 12/29/2000 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PacifiCorp's filings, including (1) Reply to Wah Motion for Interim Relief; (2) Affidavit of Bruce Griswold; (3) Affidavit of Jay Zollingers in support of that Reply, includes Exhibit A (copy of Wah Chang's Complaint in Linn County Circuit Court seeking a jury trial) and Exhibit B (PacifiCorp's Master Electric Service Agreement/Wah Chang Technical Assessment Package, August 1997), is confidential and locked in envelope #181(8); and (4) PacifiCorp's Answer and Affirmative Defenses to Wah Chang's Petition, faxed by Jay Zollinger on behalf of Lawrence Reichman. Hard Copy rec'd 1/2/01  Date: 12/18/2000 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Lowell Bergen's Ruling Granting an Extension of Time for Pacificorp to respond to Wah Chang's petition to 12/29/00. Faxed and mailed 12/18/00 to service list.   Date: 12/15/2000 Action:  OTHER CORRESPONDENCE (ACKN, SVC, LTR)      Description Letter request to remove Andy Macritchie from the service list. Filed by Jay Zollinger.  Date: 12/14/2000 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Wah Chang's Opposition to Motion for Extension of time and Exhibit A (letter and Wall Street Journal price index), faxed by Richard H. Williams. Hard copy rec'd 12/15/00.  Date: 12/14/2000 Action:  MOTION      Description PacifiCorp's Motion for an Extension of Time to Respond to Petition, Motion for Interim Relief, and Data request to 12/29/00, faxed by Lawrence Reichman. Hard copy rec'd 12/15/00.  Date: 12/13/2000 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Petitioner's letter stating that Wah Chang believes that PacifiCorp has had ample time to arrange for other legal representation; Petitioner requests interim and permanent relief from unjust and unreasonable rates imposed on Wah Chang by reason of the broken wholesale bulk power market in California. as reflected in the Dow COB index (attached); and Petitioner requests an immediate conference, faxed by Richard H. Williams.  Date: 12/8/2000 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description WAH CHANG's First Data Request - Request Nos. 1 - 10 (response date not later than 12/15/01). Filed by Richard H. Williams. (dated 12/1/00 - received in hearings 12/8/00)  Date: 12/8/2000 Action:  MOTION      Description WAH CHANG's Motion for Interim Relief and Request for Expedited Hearing w/supporting Memorandum of Law and Affidavit of Richard H. Williams. Filed by Richard H. Williams. (dated 12/1/00 - received in hearings 12/8/00)  Date: 12/1/2000 Action:  INITIAL (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description WAH CHANG, Petitioner, vs. PACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER, Respondent. In The Matter of the Petition to Protect WAH CHANG from paying unjust and unreasonable costs for power thru PACIFICORP, filed pursuant to OAR 860-013-0020 and ORS 756.040(1). Supporting exhibits: A/1-7/Master Electric Service Agreement between PACIFICORP and WAH CHANG; B/1-5/Staff Report for Public Meeting September 9, 1997 (Regular Agenda Item No. 3) - PACIFICORP (Advice 97-176) Master Electric Service Agreement between PACIFICORP and WAH CHANG; C-1/PACIFIC POWER - Calculation of Billing - October 09, 2000; C-2/PACIFIC POWER - Calculation of Billing - November 07, 2000; D/Dow Jones COB Index Since Inception. Filed by Richard H. Williams. (dated 12/1/00 - received in hearings 12/8/00)