Docket No:  NC 405 Docket Name:  CITY OF PORTLAND ACTING THRU BUREAU OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Submit Public Comment * This docket is a contested case. See the Internal Operating Guidelines and OAR 860-001 NC 405 - PUC, Complainant v. City of Portland, Bureau of Environmental Services. Complaint alleging one violation of OUNC rules, of OAR 952-001-0070, seeking penalties of up to $1,000; filed by Stephanie Andrus. Complaint served by PUC by U.S. Mail... Filing Date:  2/24/2023       Case Manager:  PAULO PINTO Phone:  971-375-2774 Email:   paulo.pinto@puc.oregon.gov Law Judge:  SARAH SPRUCE Phone:  (971) 388-6275   Email Service List (semi-colon delimited)      Email Service List (comma delimited)   If you experience problems with the above 'Email Service List' links, please try one of these: Service List Popup (semi-colon delimited)     Service List Popup (comma delimited)

ACTIONS SERVICE LIST SCHEDULE Public Comments Sort By Date        Sort By Type Date: 4/25/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTIONS GRANTED; TESTIMONY AND EXHIBITS ADMITTED. Copies served on 4/25/24.  Date: 4/24/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Admit Exhibits together with Declaration of Kevin Hennessy; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 4/24/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT. Copies served on 4/24/24.  Date: 4/22/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description ACWA's Motion to Admit Testimony together with Declarations of Steve Fancher, Jessica MacClanahan, Susie Smith, and Jennifer Wirsing; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 4/22/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description League of Oregon Cities' Motion to Admit Testimony together with Declaration of Jayme Pierce; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 4/19/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description City of Portland's Motion to Admit Testimony with Declarations of Melanie Gualotunia, Paul Suto, Lynda Hofmann, and Justin Buchanan; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 3/1/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Staff's Reply Brief, filed by Stephanie Andrus.   Date: 2/29/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description League of Oregon Cities and Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies Closing Brief. Filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 2/29/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description City of Portland's Closing Brief. Filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 2/28/2024 Action:  ORAL ARGUMENTS      Description NOTICE OF ORAL ARGUMENT. Copies served 2/28/24. ORAL ARGUMENTS scheduled 4/30/2024 1:30 PM Room: VIA ZOOM Reporter: DIGITAL Law Judge: SPRUCE, SARAH   Date: 2/28/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM ON ORAL ARGUMENT DATE. Copies served on 2/28/24.  Date: 2/2/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Staff's Opening Brief; filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 2/1/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Intervenors' League of Oregon Cities and Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies Opening Brief; filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 1/31/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description City of Portland's Opening Brief; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 1/18/2024 Action:  SERVICE LIST CHANGE      Description ACWA's Request to Change Service List to update Jerry Linder's email address; filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 1/17/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 1/17/24.  Date: 1/17/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule, expedited consideration requested; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 12/7/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: BRIEFING SCHEDULE AND DATE FOR ORAL ARGUMENTS ESTABLISHED. Copies served on 12/7/23.  Date: 12/6/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Parties' Proposed Procedural Schedule; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 12/4/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Reply Testimony of Justin Buchanan (COP/600, Buchanan) to Staff's Bench Requests responses; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 11/21/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM ON THE REMAINING PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE. Copies served on 11/21/23.  Date: 11/3/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Reply to Bench Request Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (Staff/300, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 10/30/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Bench Response Testimony of Melanie Gualotunia (City of Portland/400-402, Gualotunia) and Lynda Hofmann (City of Portland/500, Hofmann); filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 10/4/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Bench Requests. Copies served on 10/4/23.  Date: 9/15/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM MOTION TO WAIVE THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING GRANTED; BENCH REQUESTS TO BE ISSUED. Copies served on 9/15/23.  Date: 9/8/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ACWA's and LOC's Response to Motion to Waive Evidentiary Hearing; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 9/7/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING AND DEADLINES. Copies served on 9/7/23.  Date: 9/6/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Waive Hearing; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 9/6/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING. Copies served on 9/6/23.  Date: 8/31/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Reply Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (STAFF/200-203, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 8/17/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description ACWA's Response Testimony of Susie Smith (ACWA/100, Smith), Steve Fancher (ACWA/200, Fancher), Jennifer Wirsing (ACWA/300, Wirsing), and Jessica MacClanahan (ACWA/400, MacClanahan); filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 8/17/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description League of Oregon Cities' Response Testimony of Jayme Pierce (LOC/100, Pierce);filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 7/24/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Response Testimony of Melanie Gualotunia (City of Portland/100-103, Gualotunia), Paul Suto (City of Portland/200, Suto), and Lynda Hofmann (City of Portland/300, Hofmann); filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 7/6/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Opening Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (Staff/100-105, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 6/29/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO FURTHER MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 6/29/23.  Date: 6/29/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule, expedited consideration requested; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus  Date: 6/26/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 6/26/23.  Date: 6/21/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 6/21/23.  Date: 6/21/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule (Expedited Consideration Requested); filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 6/13/2023 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description League of Oregon Cities' Petition to Intervene with contacts of Jayme Pierce and Laura Maffei. Filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 5/17/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues a Ruling DISPOSITION: PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE ESTABLISHED. Copies Served on 5/17/2023.  Date: 5/11/2023 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Staff's Proposed Procedural Schedule; filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 5/8/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 5/8/23.   Date: 5/5/2023 Action:  SERVICE LIST CHANGE      Description Staff's Service List Change to remove Johanna Riemenschneider, filed by Pam Rojek.  Date: 5/2/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REQUESTING PROPOSALS FOR PROCEDUAL SCHEDULE. Copies served on 5/2/23.  Date: 4/28/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Defendant's Answer, together with Exhibit A and Exhibit B Declaration of Lynda Hofmann; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 4/25/2023 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies (ACWA) Petition to Intervene with contacts of Susie Smith, Jerry Linder, and Laura Maffei; filed by Susie Smith.  Date: 3/28/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief Administrative Law Judge Nolan Moser issues Memorandum. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 3/28/23.   Date: 3/23/2023 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. Copies served to service list on 3/23/23. CONFERENCE scheduled 3/30/2023 2:00 PM Room: ZOOMReporter: DIGITAL Law Judge: MOSER, NOLAN   Date: 3/20/2023 Action:  OTHER CORRESPONDENCE (ACKN, SVC, LTR)      Description Certified Mail Return Receipt signed by Scott R. Warnke on 3/2/23.  Date: 3/10/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief ALJ Nolan Moser issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED. Copies served electronically on 3/10/23 and by U.S. Mail to Defendant on 3/10/23, together with a courtesy electronic copy on 3/10/23.  Date: 3/10/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Defendant's Motion For an Extension of Time, expedited consideration requested; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 2/24/2023 Action:  INITIAL (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description NC 405 - PUC, Complainant v. City of Portland, Bureau of Environmental Services. Complaint alleging one violation of OUNC rules, of OAR 952-001-0070, seeking penalties of up to $1,000; filed by Stephanie Andrus. Complaint served by PUC by U.S. Mail on 2/24/23, together with a courtesy electronic copy on 2/24/23.