Docket No:  NC 405 Docket Name:  CITY OF PORTLAND ACTING THRU BUREAU OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Submit Public Comment * This docket is a contested case. See the Internal Operating Guidelines and OAR 860-001 NC 405 - PUC, Complainant v. City of Portland, Bureau of Environmental Services. Complaint alleging one violation of OUNC rules, of OAR 952-001-0070, seeking penalties of up to $1,000; filed by Stephanie Andrus. Complaint served by PUC by U.S. Mail... Filing Date:  2/24/2023       Case Manager:  PAULO PINTO Phone:  971-375-2774 Email:   paulo.pinto@puc.oregon.gov Law Judge:  SARAH SPRUCE Phone:  (971) 388-6275   Email Service List (semi-colon delimited)      Email Service List (comma delimited)   If you experience problems with the above 'Email Service List' links, please try one of these: Service List Popup (semi-colon delimited)     Service List Popup (comma delimited)

ACTIONS SERVICE LIST SCHEDULE Public Comments Sort By Date        Sort By Type Date: 5/31/2024 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff Testimony in Response to Supplemental City of Portland Testimony of Kevin Hennesy (STAFF/400, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie S. Andrus. (SEE other 5/31/24 entry for electronic version.)  Date: 5/31/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff Request to File Responsive Exhibit and Staff Response to the City of Portland's Request to File Supplemental Exhibit; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus. (SEE other 5/31/24 entry for electronic version.)  Date: 5/31/2024 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Staff Response to the City of Portland's Request to File Supplemental Exhibit and Staff Request to File Responsive Exhibit together with Attestation of Kevin Hennessy, and Staff Testimony in Response to Supplemental City of Portland Testimony of Kevin Hennesy (STAFF/400, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 5/24/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description City of Portland's Motion to Allow Additional Testimony and Amend the Procedural Schedule, filed by Eric Shaffner.   Date: 5/24/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description City of Portland's Motion to Correct Transcript, filed by Eric Shaffner.   Date: 5/7/2024 Action:  TRANSCRIPT      Description Transcript for the April 30, Oral Argument. (Not posted.) Please contact transcriber Jennifer Muir for copies at: Jennifer Muir, CET CourtScripts LLC Certified Digital Legal Transcriber 541-207-7412 jmuirtranscriber@gmail.com www.CourtScriptsllc.com  Date: 4/25/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTIONS GRANTED; TESTIMONY AND EXHIBITS ADMITTED. Copies served on 4/25/24.  Date: 4/24/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Admit Exhibits together with Declaration of Kevin Hennessy; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 4/24/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT. Copies served on 4/24/24.  Date: 4/22/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description ACWA's Motion to Admit Testimony together with Declarations of Steve Fancher, Jessica MacClanahan, Susie Smith, and Jennifer Wirsing; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 4/22/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description League of Oregon Cities' Motion to Admit Testimony together with Declaration of Jayme Pierce; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 4/19/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description City of Portland's Motion to Admit Testimony with Declarations of Melanie Gualotunia, Paul Suto, Lynda Hofmann, and Justin Buchanan; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 3/1/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Staff's Reply Brief, filed by Stephanie Andrus.   Date: 2/29/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description League of Oregon Cities and Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies Closing Brief. Filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 2/29/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description City of Portland's Closing Brief. Filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 2/28/2024 Action:  ORAL ARGUMENTS      Description NOTICE OF ORAL ARGUMENT. Copies served 2/28/24. ORAL ARGUMENTS scheduled 4/30/2024 1:30 PM Room: VIA ZOOM Reporter: DIGITAL Law Judge: SPRUCE, SARAH   Date: 2/28/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM ON ORAL ARGUMENT DATE. Copies served on 2/28/24.  Date: 2/2/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Staff's Opening Brief; filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 2/1/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description Intervenors' League of Oregon Cities and Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies Opening Brief; filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 1/31/2024 Action:  BRIEF      Description City of Portland's Opening Brief; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 1/18/2024 Action:  SERVICE LIST CHANGE      Description ACWA's Request to Change Service List to update Jerry Linder's email address; filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 1/17/2024 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 1/17/24.  Date: 1/17/2024 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule, expedited consideration requested; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 12/7/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: BRIEFING SCHEDULE AND DATE FOR ORAL ARGUMENTS ESTABLISHED. Copies served on 12/7/23.  Date: 12/6/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Parties' Proposed Procedural Schedule; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 12/4/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Reply Testimony of Justin Buchanan (COP/600, Buchanan) to Staff's Bench Requests responses; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 11/21/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM ON THE REMAINING PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE. Copies served on 11/21/23.  Date: 11/3/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Reply to Bench Request Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (Staff/300, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 10/30/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Bench Response Testimony of Melanie Gualotunia (City of Portland/400-402, Gualotunia) and Lynda Hofmann (City of Portland/500, Hofmann); filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 10/4/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Bench Requests. Copies served on 10/4/23.  Date: 9/15/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM MOTION TO WAIVE THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING GRANTED; BENCH REQUESTS TO BE ISSUED. Copies served on 9/15/23.  Date: 9/8/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ACWA's and LOC's Response to Motion to Waive Evidentiary Hearing; filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 9/7/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING AND DEADLINES. Copies served on 9/7/23.  Date: 9/6/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Waive Hearing; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 9/6/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REGARDING THE EVIDENTIARY HEARING. Copies served on 9/6/23.  Date: 8/31/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Reply Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (STAFF/200-203, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 8/17/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description ACWA's Response Testimony of Susie Smith (ACWA/100, Smith), Steve Fancher (ACWA/200, Fancher), Jennifer Wirsing (ACWA/300, Wirsing), and Jessica MacClanahan (ACWA/400, MacClanahan); filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 8/17/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description League of Oregon Cities' Response Testimony of Jayme Pierce (LOC/100, Pierce);filed by Laura C. Maffei.  Date: 7/24/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description City of Portland's Response Testimony of Melanie Gualotunia (City of Portland/100-103, Gualotunia), Paul Suto (City of Portland/200, Suto), and Lynda Hofmann (City of Portland/300, Hofmann); filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 7/6/2023 Action:  TESTIMONY & EXHIBITS      Description Staff's Opening Testimony of Kevin Hennessy (Staff/100-105, Hennessy); filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 6/29/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO FURTHER MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 6/29/23.  Date: 6/29/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule, expedited consideration requested; filed by Stephanie S. Andrus  Date: 6/26/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 6/26/23.  Date: 6/21/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: MOTION TO MODIFY SCHEDULE ON AN EXPEDITED BASIS GRANTED. Copies served on 6/21/23.  Date: 6/21/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Staff's Motion to Modify Procedural Schedule (Expedited Consideration Requested); filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 6/13/2023 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description League of Oregon Cities' Petition to Intervene with contacts of Jayme Pierce and Laura Maffei. Filed by Laura Maffei.  Date: 5/17/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues a Ruling DISPOSITION: PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE ESTABLISHED. Copies Served on 5/17/2023.  Date: 5/11/2023 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Staff's Proposed Procedural Schedule; filed by Stephanie Andrus.  Date: 5/8/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues Ruling: DISPOSITION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 5/8/23.   Date: 5/5/2023 Action:  SERVICE LIST CHANGE      Description Staff's Service List Change to remove Johanna Riemenschneider, filed by Pam Rojek.  Date: 5/2/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description ALJ Sarah Spruce issues MEMORANDUM REQUESTING PROPOSALS FOR PROCEDUAL SCHEDULE. Copies served on 5/2/23.  Date: 4/28/2023 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Defendant's Answer, together with Exhibit A and Exhibit B Declaration of Lynda Hofmann; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 4/25/2023 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies (ACWA) Petition to Intervene with contacts of Susie Smith, Jerry Linder, and Laura Maffei; filed by Susie Smith.  Date: 3/28/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief Administrative Law Judge Nolan Moser issues Memorandum. Notice of Contested Case Hearing rights attached. Copies served to service list on 3/28/23.   Date: 3/23/2023 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. Copies served to service list on 3/23/23. CONFERENCE scheduled 3/30/2023 2:00 PM Room: ZOOMReporter: DIGITAL Law Judge: MOSER, NOLAN   Date: 3/20/2023 Action:  OTHER CORRESPONDENCE (ACKN, SVC, LTR)      Description Certified Mail Return Receipt signed by Scott R. Warnke on 3/2/23.  Date: 3/10/2023 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief ALJ Nolan Moser issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED. Copies served electronically on 3/10/23 and by U.S. Mail to Defendant on 3/10/23, together with a courtesy electronic copy on 3/10/23.  Date: 3/10/2023 Action:  MOTION      Description Defendant's Motion For an Extension of Time, expedited consideration requested; filed by Eric Shaffner.  Date: 2/24/2023 Action:  INITIAL (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description NC 405 - PUC, Complainant v. City of Portland, Bureau of Environmental Services. Complaint alleging one violation of OUNC rules, of OAR 952-001-0070, seeking penalties of up to $1,000; filed by Stephanie Andrus. Complaint served by PUC by U.S. Mail on 2/24/23, together with a courtesy electronic copy on 2/24/23.