Docket No:  UM 1535 Docket Name:  PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY Subject Company:  PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC     In the Matter of PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY Request for Proposals for Capacity and Baseload Energy Resources. (fka, Request for Proposals for Capacity Resources). Filed by V. Denise Saunders. Filing Date:  3/22/2011       Final Order:  13-056 Order Signed:  2/25/2013   Email Service List (semi-colon delimited)      Email Service List (comma delimited)   If you experience problems with the above 'Email Service List' links, please try one of these: Service List Popup (semi-colon delimited)     Service List Popup (comma delimited) ACTIONS SERVICE LIST SCHEDULE Sort By Date        Sort By Type Date: 4/16/2013 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PGE's Request for Change to Service List, adding Jay Tinker and removing Randy Dahlgren. Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 4/17/13.   Date: 2/27/2013 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description CUB's Request for Change to Persons Bound by Protective Order, removing Gordon Feighner; Filed electronically by Sommer Templet. Hard copy rec'd 2/28/13.   Date: 2/25/2013 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   13-056    Description Order No. 13-056, signed by Commissioners Susan K. Ackerman, John Savage, and Stephen M. Bloom; DISPOSITION: REQUEST FOR INVESTIGATION DENIED. Copies electronically served on 2/25/13.   Date: 2/22/2013 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's Reply and Exhibits to NIPPC's Comments (Exhibits 1 and 2); Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Confidential Exhibits located in locked cabinet in Env. No. 551(6). Hard copy rec'd 2/25/13.   Date: 2/14/2013 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Addendum to the Final Report of the Independent Evaluator; Filed electronically by Stephanie S. Andrus of Staff. Hard copy rec'd 2/14/13.   Date: 2/13/2013 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC's Comments Regarding PGE's Request for Proposals; Filed electronically by Robert D. Kahn. Hard copy rec'd 2/19/13.   Date: 1/31/2013 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Independent Evaluator Report for PGE 2012 Capacity Power Supply Resources RFP; Filed electronically by Stephanie S. Andrus of Staff. Hard copy rec'd 1/31/13. (CONFIDENTIAL version located in locked cabinet env. no. 551(5)), rec'd in hard copy 2/1/13). (See also 2/14/13 Addendum filing).  Date: 1/15/2013 Action:  SERVICE LIST CHANGE      Description CUB's Notice of Change to Service List, removing Gordon Feighner and adding CUB Oregon Dockets; electronically filed by Sommer Templet. Hard copy rec'd. 1/16/13.  Date: 12/26/2012 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief ALJ Michael Grant issues Ruling; DISPOSTION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Copies electronically served 12/26/12.   Date: 12/19/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description TROUTDALE ENERGY CENTER's Reply to PGE's Response Opposing TEC's Petition to Intervene; filed electronically by Chad M. Stokes and Paula E. Pyron. Hard copy rec'd 12/20/12.  Date: 12/17/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's Response to Troutdale Energy Center LLC's Petition to Intervene; filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 12/18/12.   Date: 12/14/2012 Action:  MOTION      Description TEPPER LLC's Motion to Withdraw as a Party; Filed electronically by Richard Lorenz. Hard copy rec'd 12/18/12.   Date: 12/5/2012 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description TROUTDALE ENERGY CENTER, LLC's, Petition to Intervene, with contacts of Chad M. Stokes and Paula E. Pyron. Filed electronically by Chad M. Stokes and Paula E. Pyron. Hard copy rec'd 12-6-12.  Date: 10/29/2012 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Chief ALJ Michael Grant issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: PETITION TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Notice of Contested Case Rights, pursuant to ORS 183.413 attached to electronic version. Copies electronically served 10/29/12.  Date: 10/24/2012 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description PACIFICORP's Petition to Intervene, with contacts of Mary Wiencke, Bryce Dalley, and PacifiCorp Oregon Dockets; Filed electronically by Mary Wiencke. Hard copy rec'd 10/25/12.  Date: 10/23/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Report of the Independent Evaluator of issues raised by Troutdale Energy Center's 10/5/12 letter; Electronically submitted by Accion Group. Hard copy rec'd 10/23/12.  Date: 10/23/2012 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   12-398    Description Order No. 12-398, signed by Commissioners Susan K. Ackerman, John Savage, and Stephen M. Bloom; DISPOSITION: REQUEST FOR REHEARING DENIED; PGE DIRECTED TO EXTEND RFP SCHEDULE BY TEN (10) BUSINESS DAYS. Copies electronically served 10/23/12.  Date: 10/23/2012 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description ODOE's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Renee M. France. Qualified person thereunder: Renee M. France.  Date: 10/23/2012 Action:  NOTICE      Description ODOE's Notice of Substitution of Counsel, substituting Renee M. France for Janet L. Prewitt as counsel for ODOE. Filed electronically by Renee M. France.  Date: 10/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ICNU's Comments in response to issues raised by Troutdale Energy Center; Filed electronically by Irion Sanger. Hard copy rec'd 10/23/12.  Date: 10/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC's Reply to PGE's Response; electronically filed by Gregory Adams. Hard copy rec'd 10/25/12. (CONFIDENTIAL version located in locked cabinet, env. no. 551(4)).  Date: 10/17/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's Reply to NIPPC's Response; Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders; hard copy rec'd 10/18/12.  Date: 10/12/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's redacted Response to Troutdale Energy Center's Request for Hearing for RFP Scoring Clarification filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders; hard copy rec'd 10/15/12. Confidential portions to locked cabinet #551(3).  Date: 10/12/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC's Response in Support of Troutdale Energy Center's Request for Hearing filed electronically by Gregory Adams; hard copy rec'd 12/15/12.  Date: 10/5/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Troutdale Energy Center's Letter to Commissioners filed electronically and hard copy by Chad M. Stokes.  Date: 6/7/2012 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   12-215    Description Order No. 12-215, signed by Commissioners John Savage and Susan K. Ackerman; DISPOSITION: FINAL DRAFT RFP APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS. Copies electronically served 6-7-12.  Date: 6/1/2012 Action:  STAFF REPORT      Description Staff Report for June 5, 2012 Public Meeting (Item No. 3); Filed by Erik Colville. (Public Meeting Information is located on the PUC website at http://www.puc.state.or.us/puc/Pages/meetings/pmemos/2012/060512/Agenda.aspx (cut and paste into browser).  Date: 6/1/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description ICNU's Letter to Commissioners (FOR MEETING ON JUNE 5, 2012); Electronically filed by Irion Sanger. Hard copy rec'd 6/4/12.  Date: 5/29/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's Reply Comments REDACTED; filed electronically and hard copy by V. Denise Saunders.  Date: 5/18/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's REPLY COMMENTS; Confidential filing located in env. #551(2) in locked cabinet. Electronically filed by V. Denise Saunders.  Date: 5/15/2012 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description PGE's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Cece L. Coleman. Qualified person thereunder: Cece L. Coleman. Hard copy rec'd 5/16/12.  Date: 5/14/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Report of the Independent Evaluator for PGE 2012 Capacity Power Supply Resources RFP; Electronically filed by Stephanie Andrus. Hard copy rec'd 5/14/12.  Date: 5/11/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ICNU Letter regarding comments filed electronically by Irion A. Sanger. Hard copy rec'd 5/14/12.  Date: 5/11/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description STAFF's Specification Comments; Filed by Erik Colville.  Date: 5/10/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC's Comments on PGE's Owner's Costs; cover letter filed electronically by Gregory M. Adams. Hard copy of CONFIDENTIAL comments rec'd 5/11/12. (CONFIDENTIAL filing is located in locked cabinet, env. no. 551).  Date: 5/4/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PGE's Letter regarding Technical Specifications & Owner's Costs; [Confidential portion of filing (4 CDs) are located in env #551(1) in locked cabinet.]; Filed by Denise Saunders. Hard copies rec'd 5/7/12.  Date: 4/30/2012 Action:  NOTICE      Description CUB's Notice of Change to Signatory Pages, removing John Sturm as a qualified person under protective order; Filed electronically by Sommer Templet. Hard copy rec'd 5/1/12.  Date: 4/16/2012 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description NIPPC's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Nina M. Curtis. Qualified person thereunder: Allen R. Kasper. Hard copy rec'd 4/18/12.  Date: 3/7/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description PGE's Reply Comments; Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 3/8/12.  Date: 2/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ICNU's Comments; Filed electronically by Irion A. Sanger. Hard copy rec'd 2/23/12.  Date: 2/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description CUB's Comments on Final Draft RFP; Filed electronically by Gordon Feighner. Hard copy rec'd 2/23/12.  Date: 2/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC"s Comments with Attachment 1; Electronically filed by Gregory M. Adams. Hard copy rec'd 2/24/12.  Date: 2/22/2012 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Staff's Comments on PGE's final draft request for proposals for capacity baseload energy resources; Electronically filed by Erik Colville. Hard copy rec'd 2/22/12.  Date: 2/9/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Staff's Report of Individual Evaluator for PGE 2011 Capacity Power Supply Resources RFP. Electronically filed by Stephanie Andrus. Hard copy rec'd 2/13/12.  Date: 1/25/2012 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PGE's final draft Request for Proposal for Power Supply Resources; together with Appendices J, K, L, and M; Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 1/26/12.  Date: 1/18/2012 Action:  LAW JUDGE CONFERENCE REPORT      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Prehearing Conference Memorandum adopting schedule; Copies electronically served 1/18/12.  Date: 1/6/2012 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF PREHEARING CONFERENCE; Copies electronically served to docket UM 1535 on 1/6/12. CONFERENCE scheduled 1/17/2012 1:30 PM City: SALEM Room: MAIN HEARING RM Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Dial in available, contact AHD at 503-378-6678 or puc.hearings@state.or.us for number and port. Reporter: DIGITAL Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK   Date: 1/6/2012 Action:  AMENDED (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description Docket UM 1535 is renamed In the Matter of PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY Request for Proposals for Capacity and Baseload Energy Resources. (See ALJ Ruling 1/6/12)  Date: 1/6/2012 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description UM 1534, UM 1535--ALJ Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: DOCKET UM 1535 RENAMED; DOCKET UM 1534 CLOSED. Copies served electronically to dockets UM 1534 and UM 1535 1/6/12.  Date: 1/5/2012 Action:  MOTION      Description PGE's letter to Commission regarding status of docket and requesting prehearing conference; Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 1/9/12.  Date: 12/30/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description CUB's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Sommer Templet. Qualified person thereunder: Sommer Templet. Hard copy rec'd 1/3/12.  Date: 9/27/2011 Action:  ORDER      Order No:   11-371    Description Order No. 11-371 signed by Commissioners John Savage and Susan K. Ackerman; DISPOSITION: REQUESTS FOR PROPOSALS COMBINED; CONDITIONS ADOPTED; Served electronically 9/27/11.  Date: 7/21/2011 Action:  STAFF REPORT      Description Staff Report for July 26, 2011 Public Meeting (Item No. 2); filed by Erik Colville. Electronic version of Staff Report is available at http://www.puc.state.or.us/PUC/meetings/pmemos/2011/072611/agenda.shtml  Date: 7/8/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Portland General Electric Company's Reply Comments; Electronically filed by V. Denise Saunders; Hard copy rec'd 7/11/11.  Date: 6/28/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description ICNU's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097, with information under paragraph 10(e); Filed electronically by Sarah A. Kohler. Hard copy rec'd 6/29/11. Persons qualified thereunder: Donald Schoenbeck & Robynn Woodbury  Date: 6/22/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description NIPPC's Comments; electronically filed by Gregory M. Adams. Hard copy rec'd 6/24/11.   Date: 6/22/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description Renewable Northwest Project's Comments; electronically filed by Kim T. Buckley. Hard copy rec'd 6/24/11.  Date: 6/22/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description ICNU's Comments on Final Draft of RFP; electronically filed by Irion Sanger. Hard copy rec'd 6/24/11.  Date: 6/22/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description CUB's Comments; electronically filed by John Sturm. Hard copies rec'd 6/24/11. Additional hard copies rec'd 6/28/11.  Date: 6/22/2011 Action:  COMMENTS/RESPONSE      Description STAFF's Comments; electronically and hard-copy filed by Erik Colville.  Date: 6/20/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description TEPPER LLC's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Electronically filed by Richard Lorenz. Hard copy rec'd 6/22/11. Qualified persons thereunder: Richard Lorenz, J. Laurence Cable, Tanya Bettineski, Shannon Kimmel, and Chuck Sides.  Date: 6/8/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description ICNU's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; electronically filed by Sarah A. Kohler. Hard copy rec'd 6/9/11. Persons qualified thereunder: Melinda J. Davison, S. Bradley Van Cleve, Irion A. Sanger, Jocelyn C. Pease, Jess E. Cowell, Sarah A. Kohler, and Jacqueline E. Smith.  Date: 6/8/2011 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description UM 1534 & UM 1535--Administrative Law Judge Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: PETITIONS TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Copies served electronically 6-8-11 to dockets UM 1534 and UM 1535.  Date: 6/7/2011 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description Accion Group's Independent Evaluator Assessment of PGE's Draft 2011 RPP; electronically and hard-copy filed by Stephanie S. Andrus.  Date: 5/24/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description TEPPER LLC's Petition to Intervene, with contacts of Chuck Sides, J. Laurence Cable and Richard Lorenz; Filed electronically by Richard Lorenz. Hard copy rec'd 5/25/11.  Date: 5/24/2011 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PGE's Errata to its Final Draft RFP; electronically filed by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 5/24/11.  Date: 5/24/2011 Action:  LAW JUDGE RULING/MEMORANDA      Description Administrative Law Judge Patrick Power issues Ruling; DISPOSITION: PETITIONS TO INTERVENE GRANTED. Copies served electronically 5/24/11.  Date: 5/23/2011 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description PGE's Final Draft Request for Proposals; electronically filed by V. Denish Saunders. Hard copy rec'd 5/24/11.  Date: 5/10/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description RENEWABLE NORTHWEST PROJECT'S Petition to Intervene, with contacts of Megan Walseth Decker, John W. Stephens, and Jimmy Lindsay; electronically filed by John W. Stephens.  Date: 4/26/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description NW ENERGY COALITION's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Wendy Gerlitz. Hard copy rec'd 4/29/11. Qualified person thereunder: Wendy Gerlitz.   Date: 4/20/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description Northwest Energy Coalition's Petition to Intervene with contact of Wendy Gerlitz; electronically filed by Wendy Gerlitz. Hard copy rec'd 4/20/11.  Date: 4/18/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description PGE's Signatory Pages related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by V. Denise Saunders. Hard copy originals rec'd 4/19/11. Qualified persons thereunder: V. Denise Saunders, Loretta Mabinton, Nuria Claudio-Mariages, Amy Brogan, Cory McAlister, James Lobdell, Stephen Quennoz, Jim Piro, Maria Pope, Stephen Hawke, Randall J. Dahlgren, Darrington Outma, Joe Eberhardt, Damon McCauley, Jerry Thale, Ted Drennan, Shelly Sayler, Brian Kuehne, Silvia Melchiorri, John Ollis, Catherine Bailey, Mike O'Shea, Ann Cunningham, Arya Behoehani, Ray Hendricks, Chris Dieterle, Steve Higgins, Brett Sims, Stefan Brown, James Eden, Matthew O' Connell, Tamara, Neizke, Jim Barnes, William Lopez, Dmitri Jemeljanov, Krystal Gema, Bruce True, Rebecca Brown, Spenser Williams, Lucia Dempsey, David Weitzel, Jennifer Tucker, Patrick G. Hager, III, and Karen Richards.   Date: 4/18/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description ODOE's Signatory Pages related to Protective Order No. 11-097, together with information under 10(d) and (e); Filed electronically by Janet C. Prewitt. Qualified persons thereunder: Janet C. Prewitt, Vijay Satyal, Matt Krumenauer, Matthew Hale, Trace Megenbier, and Rebecca Sherman. Hard copy originals rec'd 4/19/11.  Date: 4/15/2011 Action:  LAW JUDGE CONFERENCE REPORT      Description ALJ Patrick Power issues Prehearing Conference Memorandum (setting schedule); Notice of Contested Case Rights pursuant to ORS 183.413 attached. Copies electronically served 4/15/11.  Date: 4/11/2011 Action:  OTHER FILING/PLEADING      Description CUB's Notice of Intent to Request an Issue Fund Grant; Filed electronically by John C. Sturm. Hard copy rec'd 4/13/11.  Date: 4/11/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description CUB's Signatory Pages related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by John Sturm. Qualified persons thereunder: John Sturm, (G.) Catriona McCracken, Ray Myers, Bob Jenks, and Gordon Feighner. Hard copy rec'd 4/13/11. (Qualified person designation removed for John Sturm on 4/30/12). (Qualified person designation for Gordon Feighner removed 2/27/13).  Date: 4/11/2011 Action:  NOTICE      Description CITIZENS' UTILITY BOARD OF OREGON's Notice of Intervention, with contacts of G. Catriona McCracken, Bob Jenks, and Gordon Feighner. Electronically filed by John C. Sturm. Hard copy rec'd 4/13/11.  Date: 4/11/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description OREGON DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY's Petition to Intervene, listing contacts of Janet L. Prewitt, Vijay A. Satyal, and Matt Krumenauer; Filed electronically by Janet L. Prewitt. Hard copy rec'd 4/11/11.   Date: 4/8/2011 Action:  CONFERENCE      Description NOTICE OF PREHEARING CONFERENCE; Copies served electronically and via U.S. Mail 4/11/11 to UM 1535, Electric List, & dockets UE 215, UM 1345, & LC 48. PREHEARING CONFERENCE scheduled 4/15/2011 1:30 PM City: SALEM Room: MAIN HEARING RM Building: PUC Address: 550 CAPITOL ST NE Dial in: 503-365-4439, conf code 6782 (please reserve a port with AHD 503-378-6678) Reporter: TAPE Law Judge: POWER, PATRICK  Date: 3/30/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description INDUSTRIAL CUSTOMERS OF NORTHWEST UTILITIES' Petition to Intervene, with contacts of S. Bradley Van Cleve, Irion Sanger, and Donald W. Schoenbeck. Filed electronically by S. Bradley Van Cleve. Hard copy rec'd 3/31/11.  Date: 3/29/2011 Action:  SIGNATORY PAGES      Description NIPPC's Signatory Page related to Protective Order No. 11-097; Filed electronically by Gregory M. Adams. Qualified persons thereunder: Gregory M. Adams and Peter J. Richardson. Hard copy rec'd 3/31/11.  Date: 3/29/2011 Action:  PETITION TO INTERVENE      Description NORTHWEST AND INTERMOUNTAIN POWER PRODUCERS COALITION's Petition to Intervene, with contacts of Robert D. Kahn, Peter J. Richardson, and Gregory M. Adams. Filed electronically by Gregory M. Adams. Hard copy rec'd 3/31/11.  Date: 3/25/2011 Action:  PROTECTIVE ORDER      Order No:   11-097    Description Protective Order No. 11-097 signed by Administrative Law Judge Lisa D. Hardie; DISPOSITION: MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER GRANTED. Copies served electronically 3/25/11.  Date: 3/22/2011 Action:  MOTION      Description PGE's Motion for Approval of a Protective Order; filed by V. Denise Saunders. (See Initial Filing for electronic version.)  Date: 3/22/2011 Action:  INITIAL (APPLICATION, COMPLAINT, PETITION)      Description In the Matter of PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY Request for Proposals for Capacity and Baseload Energy Resources. (fka, Request for Proposals for Capacity Resources). Filed by V. Denise Saunders.